Rabinowitch writes to BR regarding Khrushchev's proposal. "If one could assume that Khruschev's proposal is not merely sincere, but also serious, and that the Pugwash Movement could mobilize public opinion for its support, I would not hesitate; but while I believe that the Russians would like to see far-reaching disarmament, to be able to concentrate on their lagging production of consumer goods, I do no believe that Khrushchev's complete disarmament proposal is meant seriously, and what is more important, I do not believe that the Pugwash Movement could be a strong influence in its support."

Rabinowitch questions the competence of the Pugwash Continuing Committee to issue statements that commit the Movement.